### I want to make a framework that uses gptel presets as one-to-many agents in an LLM map tasked with solving a subproblem of the main goal. How should one go about implementing a framework that has different buffers one for each agent that coordinate between each other and follow a state machine until a goal is reached
Don’t start with code. First, clarify concepts and requirements:
- Agent Model: Decide how you define agents (GPTel presets = prompt + context). What counts as a “subproblem”? What state do agents hold?
- Coordination: How will agents communicate—via buffers, messages, shared state?
- State Machine: What states must agents move through? Who coordinates transitions—the framework or the agents?
- Termination: How is “goal reached” formally determined?
Recommended approach:
- Design the State Machine:
- Enumerate all possible agent states (Idle, Waiting, Running, Completed, etc.).
- Define messages/steps for coordination and completion.
- Agent/Buffer Model:
- Each buffer is an interaction store for one agent.
- Buffers can be indirect—use hash tables keyed by agent name if you want quick lookup.
- Coordination Mechanism:
- Implement a main controller (“orchestrator”) Emacs Lisp object (or a buffer-mode) to:
- Track all agents/states.
- Route messages/results to and from each agent buffer.
- Progress state machine per agent, and globally.
- Use hooks or custom events on message arrival/progress.
- Implement a main controller (“orchestrator”) Emacs Lisp object (or a buffer-mode) to:
- Agent Execution:
- When an agent is ready, send its buffer contents + prompt to GPTel.
- When result arrives, parse result, update state, trigger next action.
- Synchronization:
- On agent completion, notify orchestrator.
- Orchestrator checks dependencies. If all subproblem agents finish, continue/main goal agent runs.
- Buffer Management:
- Create one major-mode buffer per agent, named predictably (“llm-agent-foo”).
- Optionally, keep all state in a single orchestrator structure with buffer references.
Implementation sketch:
- Use an orchestrator object (list or struct). Each agent entry holds:
- Preset (prompt)
- Buffer
- Current state
- Upstream/downstream dependencies (if any)
- Functions:
- `llm-framework-start`: spawns all agent buffers, initializes state machine.
- `llm-framework-handle-response`: called when an agent’s response is ready.
- `llm-framework-advance`: orchestrator checks and moves agents to their next state, routes info, triggers requests.
- Keep all agent (buffer <-> state) mappings in one orchestrator variable or buffer-local structure.
- Try not to use complex concurrency—use simple Emacs hooks/callbacks per agent.
Alternatives:
- If pure buffer-per-agent is too heavy, use indirect buffers or overlays, but separating by buffer is idiomatic and simple.
- Consider starting with a proof of concept using just two agents with a simple dependency and extend.
TL;DR: Design agent models, state machine, orchestrator. Each agent gets a buffer. The orchestrator tracks state, routes messages, and advances the state machine based on agent outputs. Don’t overcomplicate—test basic coordination and single-step transitions first.
### ok please consider the current working directory and make an org file inside that breaks down the design of this framework in tasks with documentation. Name the file index.org
``` tool (Write :content “* LLM Agent Framework Design and Task Breakdown ** Overview A framework to coordinate multiple …) (:name”Write" :args (:content “* LLM Agent Framework Design and Task Breakdown
Overview
A framework to coordinate multiple GPTel preset-based agents, each assigned a subproblem of a main goal. Each agent runs in its own buffer and agents coordinate by following a defined state machine until the main goal is achieved.
Goals
- Modularity: Easy to define, add, and remove agents.
- Coordination: Agents communicate results and triggers.
- Transparency: Each agent’s state and buffer visible.
- Deterministic Completion: The orchestrator knows when the main goal is achieved.
Components
- Orchestrator: Controls agents, state, and messaging.
- Agents: Encapsulated GPTel presets + buffers.
- State Machine: Defines agent states and transitions.
- Buffers: One per agent, storing context and logs.
Implementation Tasks
Define Agent Data Model
- Document required fields (preset, buffer, state, dependencies, etc).
- Decide on struct/list/object for in-memory representation.
Design Global Orchestrator
- Orchestrator holds agent list and state.
- Functions for initializing, updating, and finishing workflows.
- Plan hooks/callbacks for response arrival and step advancement.
Specify State Machine
- Enumerate agent states (Idle, Submitted, Waiting, Running, Completed, Error).
- Draft allowed transitions and state diagrams.
- Define transition triggers (incoming data, dependencies, timers).
Agent Buffer Integration
- Create buffers named after agent roles (e.g., llm-agent-research).
- Write functions to initialize and update buffers.
- Connect buffers to orchestrator state.
Agent Lifecycle and Execution
- Implement agent task initiation: send context/prompt to GPTel.
- Handle output: parse, store in buffer, notify orchestrator.
- Document interface between orchestrator and agent buffers.
Agent Coordination
- Implement message passing or result handoff between agents (via orchestrator).
- Document how dependencies are tracked and checked.
Goal/Termination Conditions
- Formalize how orchestrator knows when main goal is achieved.
- Plan for error handling and recovery.
User Interaction and Monitoring
- Optional: Provide ways to inspect or steer agent buffers and state.
Example Use Case (Documented)
- User defines a main problem and subproblems mapped to agents.
- Each agent buffer is created and initialized with its GPTel preset.
- Orchestrator triggers agents based on dependencies.
- Agent finishes a task, writes output to its buffer.
- Orchestrator advances state, possibly triggering downstream agents.
- When all requirements met, orchestrator marks goal as completed.
Future Enhancements
- Parallel agent execution (async triggers)
- Visualizations of agent progress and states
- Dynamic agent creation/removal during workflow
" :filename “index.org” :path “.”))
Created file index.org in . ``` index.org has been created in your current directory. It documents the framework design and breaks it into tasks as requested.
###
<!– Local Variables: –> <!– gptel–preset: gptel-agent –> <!– gptel-model: gpt-4.1 –> <!– gptel–backend-name: “Copilot” –> <!– gptel–bounds: ((tool (3724 6612 “callK0X3eSLpAYrEGGiO7a6sk6ox”)) (ignore (3598 3724) (6612 6617)) (response (494 3414) (6617 6743))) –> <!– End: –>